The release of Beyoncé’s “Cowboy Carter” has sparked discussions on the representation of Black artists in country music. It also showcases her determination to defy genre boundaries by embracing her most unconventional instincts. This image is credited to Mason Poole. Beyoncé’s bold move with “Cowboy Carter” challenges traditional norms in the music industry, emphasizing her artistic freedom and innovation. The article was initially featured in the NPR Music newsletter, offering readers exclusive content and early access to similar articles. Since its debut, “Cowboy Carter” has garnered significant attention, drawing parallels to classic Western films with its grandeur and eloquence. Beyoncé’s deliberate choice of words in this piece demonstrates her mastery of storytelling and creativity.
Exploring the Impact of “The Good, the Bey, and the Ugly”
Since the era of Taylor’s iconic tour, “The Good, the Bey, and the Ugly” has sparked numerous analytical pieces, captivating audiences and critics alike.
Monitoring the reception of “Cowboy Carter” has been a fascinating journey, with a wide spectrum of opinions ranging from admiration to critique. Music journalists have delved deep into the album’s origins, dissected its cultural references, and pondered its contribution to music history. Amidst this discourse, one undeniable truth emerges: “Cowboy Carter” is a unique and intriguing creation, defying conventional labels and expectations.
**Analyzing Beyoncé’s Unique Approach to Country Music**
**Beyoncé’s Unconventional Take on Country Music**
Beyoncé doesn’t shy away from her distinctive style. She positions herself as a dedicated student of the genre she aims to transform. In her extensive collection of ballads and upbeat tracks, she incorporates key elements of cultural redefinition. Collaborating with icons like Dolly Parton and Willie Nelson, she showcases her boots, designer jeans, and whiskey, while also delving into themes like murder ballads and her interpretation of the American flag. For Beyoncé, the flag symbolizes red, representing blood, Alabama soil, and indigenous communities.
**Recognizing Unsung Heroes in Country Music**
Beyoncé’s decision to feature the overlooked Black trailblazer Linda Martell as a partner reflects a broader movement to address historical oversights prevalent in Nashville. She pays tribute to the Black Opry collective, along with figures like artist and radio host Rissi Palmer. Additionally, she acknowledges Martell’s granddaughter, who is actively raising funds for a documentary that Beyoncé could potentially support financially.
Unique Musical Vision
She crafts a distinctive blend of country and pop, diverging from the norm by incorporating a myriad of influences. Rather than simply using these elements superficially, she delves deep into her passions, creating a cosmic tapestry of references. This album stands out not only for its grandeur and political undertones but for its individuality, reminiscent of Jim Jarmusch’s unconventional portrayals of American culture in films like Mystery Train, rather than the more mainstream approach seen in Martin Scorsese’s Killers of the Flower Moon.
Despite featuring mainstream artists like Miley Cyrus and Post Malone and gaining approval from top figures like the Vice President, Cowboy Carter exudes a sense of quirkiness. Listening to it evokes memories of a 1967 album, emphasizing the artist’s unique use of the English language.
Van Dyke Parks’s Song Cycle stands out among rock enthusiasts for its unique charm. As the first solo project of the renowned composer, arranger, and producer, it presents a whimsical and sun-soaked psychedelic portrayal of California life through the eyes of a white East Coaster with Southern origins. Born in Mississippi and raised in Princeton, where he sang in a boys’ choir, Parks infuses the album with lush strings, captivating melodies, and cleverly poetic lines like “Nowadays a Yankee dread not take his time to wend to sea,” reflecting his own struggles in the competitive L.A. music scene.
Incorporating his distinctive birdlike vocals, reminiscent of Tweety Bird or Woodstock from Peanuts, Parks showcases his musical prowess in Song Cycle, a departure from mainstream styles. While he collaborated on the unfinished psychedelic masterpiece Smile with Brian Wilson and worked with modern artists like Joanna Newsom and Gaby Moreno, Song Cycle remains his eccentric masterpiece. This album delves into the essence of the late 1960s West Coast culture, offering a profound yet unconventional musical journey that demands patience and an open mind to fully appreciate.
On the other hand, Cowboy Carter diverges significantly from the sound of Song Cycle, yet it evokes a similar non-linear and fragmented listening experience. Just as Beyoncé stays true to her artistic vision, Parks maintains his whimsical and dreamy approach throughout his work. While Song Cycle employs intricate harmonies and strings to create grandeur and intimacy in tracks like “American Requiem,” “MY ROSE,” and “FLAMENCO,” Beyoncé’s Cowboy Carter showcases a different musical landscape, highlighting her vocal prowess and storytelling abilities.
In essence, both albums offer a unique perspective on musical expression, with Song Cycle delving into experimental structures and poetic lyricism while Cowboy Carter showcases a different yet equally captivating musical narrative.
### Beyoncé’s Unique Blend of Genres and Influences
Beyoncé’s latest album seamlessly fuses various musical elements, from soulful vocals to Andalusian hand-claps, creating a surreal yet captivating Broadway-esque experience. The infusion of banjo and pedal steel, alongside unconventional instruments like accordion and balalaika, adds a distinct country flair to the tracks, showcasing Parks’ innovative approach. Unlike mainstream country music, the distortions in the album offer a refreshing and individualistic sound, with notable exceptions like the unexpected Post Malone collaboration on “LEVII’S JEANS.”
The album’s homage to roots music takes a whimsical turn on tracks like “OH LOUISIANA,” where a sped-up Chuck Berry vocal transforms the rock and roll legend into a high-pitched rendition. In the standout tribute to Tina Turner, “YA YA,” Beyoncé pays homage to the iconic singer with a playful nod to her cinematic roles and the eccentricity of Southern rap, reminiscent of Outkast’s “Hey Ya!” While rooted in history, Beyoncé’s work defies traditional norms, offering a unique and unconventional musical experience.
These eclectic tracks coalesce into a diverse mix of concepts, tempos, and tones, culminating in the energetic megamix of “Cowboy Carter.” The album’s final tracks return to the dance party vibe of “Renaissance,” culminating in the showstopping finale, “AMEN,” tailor-made for a Broadway stage. Beyoncé’s musical journey is immersive yet dynamic, akin to a thrilling rodeo ride that challenges conventional narratives and invites listeners to explore themes of love, motherhood, and personal ambition through a fresh lens.
Artists’ Creative Process in Concept Albums
Creating concept albums is more of an artistic endeavor than a privilege. Artists pour their ideas into these projects, resulting in intricate and expressive musical narratives. For instance, Beyoncé’s musical influences can be traced back to iconic albums like Sly and the Family Stone’s There’s a Riot Goin’ On and Willie Nelson’s Red Headed Stranger.
While Michael Jackson never ventured into a full concept album, his monumental impact on the music industry cannot be overlooked. Beyoncé’s ambitious projects rival those of legendary artists like Madonna with Erotica and Prince, known for his innovative soundtracks.
Recent artists like Janelle Monaé and Raphael Saadiq have also delved into the realm of high-concept albums, influencing Beyoncé’s work. Collaborators such as Shaboozie have paid homage to their roots through emotionally charged albums like Jimmy Lee and Cowboys Live Forever, Outlaws Never Die.
When considering “Cowboy Carter” alongside other innovative concept albums and their creators, it’s not about diminishing the impact of Beyoncé’s work or her influence as a defining artist of her era. Rather, it’s about liberating this vibrant and unrestricted music from predetermined meanings. Beyoncé, by choice and driven by her fans’ expectations, has evolved into what Doreen St. Felix describes as an “übermatriarch” – not just a biological mother but a nurturing figure burdened with the responsibility of caring for her followers and the Black community, a role she has embraced from the equally unconventional and somewhat reluctantly revered Aretha Franklin. The weight of her duties has brought her immense success: from millions to nearly billions of dollars, a position among world leaders, and a fan base that intimidates critics. However, such achievements can also confine an artist. Only a select few have managed to maintain a sense of playfulness and agility as their public personas solidify into unyielding statues.
Interestingly, Beyoncé challenges two such artists in “Cowboy Carter”: The Beatles, who consistently released lighthearted and nonsensical tracks alongside their more serious compositions, and Dolly Parton, the versatile pop icon known for effortlessly transitioning between various genres with her infectious laughter and warm smile. Dolly herself possesses unique and unconventional tendencies, evident in her songs about tragic themes like deceased children or her ability to portray sexuality in a whimsical and exaggerated manner, akin to a cartoon character.
Embracing the Power of Musical Innovation
When it comes to wielding her musical prowess as a weapon, Beyoncé’s unconventional nature has been her greatest ally in navigating various opportunities.
Creating Cowboy Carter wasn’t about paying homage to white artists like Parton for Beyoncé. Instead, it was a strategic move to align herself with Parton as a collaborator and a supporter. In a candid exchange before Beyoncé’s rendition of “Jolene,” Parton humorously twists Beyoncé’s iconic reference to a white woman’s appeal to her Black spouse, known as “Becky with the good hair,” into “that hussy with the good hair.” With a playful drawl reminiscent of a scene from Hee Haw, she delivers the insult as “huzzzzy.” This whimsical and entertaining moment serves as a delightful disruption, emphasizing that while music can be profound, its ability to challenge norms is most impactful when infused with humor.
Stay updated by subscribing to the NPR Music newsletter here.
